Don't you think your short appraisal of the Clash represents NMA's attempts to break the mould and try something new ?
Apologies in advance if we have already gone over this but i thought you posted on this forum something about NMA losing the aggressiveness and nothing seems the same since Vengance.....have i misinterpreted your point ??
On a final note re The Clash....what are your thoughts on 'Cut the Crap'.., this album got a horrendous write up. I can certainly remember listening to that and thinking WTF.
The Clash's "Cut The Crap" is incorrectly called a Clash album. Half of the songwriting team was gone from the band (replaced with Bernie Rhodes? A guy who never wrote a song?), three new members became a part of the band....I know it is called a Clash album, but it is unfair to do that. And no matter what band title they gave the album, it is horrendously bad. Terribly bad. Historically bad.
Having said that, the album does contain the tune "This Is England" which would make the top ten best of any band, including The Clash. That is a fantastic song. It also contains the greatest lyric Joe Strummer ever wrote. "Black shadow of the Vincent falls on a Triumph line." Man, by using the names of motorcycles and their manufacturers to perfectly encapsulate the decline in glory of an entire nation is absolutely stunning.
As far as NMA breaking the mold and being less aggressive musically and lyrically, yeah they have done that (see my new thread about "Christian Militia"). I am not a huge fan of the "gentler" road they have taken. I am not against melody and peace and love ("I Wish" is one of my top five favorite NMA songs), but I sure would like to see Justin crank up his Gibson SG a bit more and quit relying on his acoustic so much.